Alignment on all memory instructions in wasm is currently best-effort
and not actually required, meaning that whatever wasm actually uses as
an address should work regardless of whether the address is aligned or
not. This is theoretically tested in the fuzzers via
wasm-smith-generated code, but wasm-smith doesn't today have too too
high of a chance of generating an actual successful load/store.
This commit adds a new configuration option to the `Config` generator
for fuzzing which forces usage of a custom linear memory implementation
which is backed by Rust's `Vec<u8>` and forces the base address of
linear memory to be off-by-one relative to the base address of the
`Vec<u8>` itself. This should theoretically force host addresses to
almost always be unaligned, even if wasm addresses are otherwise
aligned.
The main interesting fuzz coverage here is likely to be in the existing
`differential` target which compares running the same module in wasmtime
with two different `Config` values to ensure the same results are
produced. This probably won't increase coverage all that much in the
near future due to wasm-smith rarely generating successful loads/stores,
but in the meantime by hooking this up into `Config` it also means that
we'll be running in comparison against v8 and also ensuring that all
spec tests succeed if misalignment is forced at the hardware level.
As a side effect this commit also cleans up the fuzzers slightly:
* The `DifferentialConfig` struct is removed and folded into `Config`
* The `init_hang_limit` processing is removed since we don't use
`-ttf`-generated modules from binaryen any more.
* Traps are now asserted to have the same trap code, otherwise
differential fuzzing fails.
* Some more debug logging was added to the differential fuzzer
* Update wasm-smith to 0.7.0
* Canonicalize NaN with wasm-smith for differential fuzzing
This then also enables floating point executing in wasmi in addition to
the spec interpreter. With NaN canonicalization at the wasm level this
means that we should be producing deterministic results between Wasmtime
and these alternative implementations.
* Enable simd fuzzing on oss-fuzz
This commit generally enables the simd feature while fuzzing, which
should affect almost all fuzzers. For fuzzers that just throw random
data at the wall and see what sticks, this means that they'll now be
able to throw simd-shaped data at the wall and have it stick. For
wasm-smith-based fuzzers this commit also updates wasm-smith to 0.6.0
which allows further configuring the `SwarmConfig` after generation,
notably allowing `instantiate-swarm` to generate modules using simd
using `wasm-smith`. This should much more reliably feed simd-related
things into the fuzzers.
Finally, this commit updates wasmtime to avoid usage of the general
`wasm_smith::Module` generator to instead use a Wasmtime-specific custom
default configuration which enables various features we have
implemented.
* Allow dummy table creation to fail
Tables might creation for imports may exceed the memory limit on the
store, which we'll want to gracefully recover from and not fail the
fuzzers.
This commit removes the binaryen support for fuzzing from wasmtime,
instead switching over to `wasm-smith`. In general it's great to have
what fuzzing we can, but our binaryen support suffers from a few issues:
* The Rust crate, binaryen-sys, seems largely unmaintained at this
point. While we could likely take ownership and/or send PRs to update
the crate it seems like the maintenance is largely on us at this point.
* Currently the binaryen-sys crate doesn't support fuzzing anything
beyond MVP wasm, but we're interested at least in features like bulk
memory and reference types. Additionally we'll also be interested in
features like module-linking. New features would require either
implementation work in binaryen or the binaryen-sys crate to support.
* We have 4-5 fuzz-bugs right now related to timeouts simply in
generating a module for wasmtime to fuzz. One investigation along
these lines in the past revealed a bug in binaryen itself, and in any
case these bugs would otherwise need to get investigated, reported,
and possibly fixed ourselves in upstream binaryen.
Overall I'm not sure at this point if maintaining binaryen fuzzing is
worth it with the advent of `wasm-smith` which has similar goals for
wasm module generation, but is much more readily maintainable on our
end.
Additonally in this commit I've added a fuzzer for wasm-smith's
`SwarmConfig`-based fuzzer which should expand the coverage of tested
modules.
Closes#2163
